Help Save Andrea Clark
[SEE UPDATES BELOW]
Like John Hawkins, I also saw this last night while snooping around the DU, and had intended to post something about it but stupidly forgot until just now–thanks to John for the reminder.
And like John did, I’m just going to re-post the whole thing she wrote, because it is URGENT.
KILLING MY SISTER - WE ARE PROTESTING - HELP US
Mods, please don’t move this post. I know it’s not in the activist section, but there’s so little time left now, we need it to reach as many people as possible. We desperately need help.
Fellow DUers:
My sister, Andrea Clarke, is at St. Luke’s Episcopal Hospital in Houston, TX. St. Luke’s is located at:
6720 Bertner Avenue, Houston, TX. Their phone number is: 832-355-1000.
The hospital ethics committee met the day before yesterday and concluded that Andrea’s treatment (respirator and dialysis) should be discontinued. We have ten days to move her from that hospital or they will “pull the plug” and let Andrea die. Andrea, until a few days ago, when the physicians decided to increase her pain medication and anesthetize her into unconsciousness, was fully able to make her own medical decisions and had decided that she wanted life saving treatment until she dies naturally. We have learned that this is part of the process, when hospitals decided to declare the “medical futility” of continueing treatment for a patient. But, this is not a Terry Schiavo case; not anything like it. Andrea, when she is not medicated into unconsciousness (and even when she is, and the medication has worn off to some degree) is aware and cognizant. She has suffered no brain damage to the parts of her brain responsible for thought and reason, or speech. She has only suffered loss of some motor control. The reason that the physician gave to medicate her so much is that she is suffering from intractable pain in the sacral region (in other words, she has a bedsore that causes her pain). This is not reason enough, in our books, and we are trying, as we speak, to get Andrea’s medication lowered so that she can speak to us.
There is also some disagreement as to whether Andrea is really in that much pain, as well. When she is not medicated to this degree, and she sees her son, Charles, she smiles. She also mouths words (Andrea is very vocal, normally, even with a trach, and asks for food, etc., when she is not medicated to the gills). Once again, this is not like the Shiavo case, where there was brain death. Andrea has voiced her wishes, over and over again, and if she were not on so much pain medication, she would voice them again.
Houston hospitals have a policy in that once the medical treatment of a patient has been deemed “medically futile” no other hospital in the area will accept transfer of that patient to their facility. This means that the patient, who is usually in a very delicate condition anyway, has to be transported over a long distance, in order to receive care.
We received notice of the ethics committee decision the day before yesterday and we are organizing a protest to take place tomorrow, at 2-2:30pm outside St. Luke’s Episcopal Hospital. Our family members number four and we will all be there, but we need more people. Please help us.
This protest is very likely to be filmed and get news coverage.
For those of you who will reply to this post with more questions, please see my other posts on this topic. I have done my best to answer all of your questions, but as you can imagine, my mind is not working as efficiently as it should, because I am upset. I assure you this is real; this is happening, and in Texas, medical professionals have the right, under the Futile Care Law, to discontinue life saving treatment, under these circumstances, even while the patient and the family is protesting that action. If you need more information, please see my other posts on this topic. For now, we need help, not questions or suggestions as to further courses of action. We are fighting on all fronts, ie., lawyers, news media, churches, internet, etc. We have left no stone unturned in this battle.
Many, many people, even some medical professionals in Texas, and other areas, don’t know about this law. They have no idea that this can be done, and it is is being done every day in Texas hospitals, but is not covered by the news media. This needs to become common knowledge and this law needs to be overturned, of course, but we are fighting for the life of our sister. We are fighting to see that her wishes about how she lives, and how she dies, are honored. Perhaps these kinds of battles are fought in just this way, one by one, out of love, and this is how the war is won, in the end.
Please help us. Please lend your presence to our fight at St. Luke’s Episcopal Hospital in Houston, Texas, located at 6720 Bertner Ave. at 2-2:30pm CST tomorrow (Saturday). If you would like to bring a sign, please do so, because we only have a limited amount. If you don’t, then please just bring yourself.
My name is Melanie Childers and my cell phone number is: (see it at the original post)
My sister (not the one in the hospital, but the one handling the protest) is Lanore Dixon and her numbers are: (see them at the original post). Please do not call us unless you are calling to request some information that I have not posted here. We have our phones glued to our heads, trying to find a hospital that will take Andrea, before her ten days are up at St. Luke’s Episcopal Hospital. I am posting these numbers only to show you that this is not some kind of scam, or a joke or something even more idiotic.
Please help us.
ProLife Blogs is also carrying the story.
More about medical “ethics” here. I’m not even going to go down that road again in this post, because I am furious. HOW DARE THEY.
Note: Yes, this came from the DU. Don’t even think about making hypocritical snide remarks. Politics do not matter when it comes to a human life, and hopefully I don’t have to tell anyone here that. (I just noticed a few stupid comments elsewhere.) Politics is OFF-LIMITS.
Get on the phone. Again, the info:
Andrea Clarke is at St. Luke’s Episcopal Hospital in Houston, TX. St. Luke’s is located at:
6720 Bertner Avenue, Houston, TX. Their phone number is: 832-355-1000.
Here’s the website, and a general email address.
Even better, if you’re in Texas, call or write your elected officials. I’m also going to email Not Dead Yet.
Please spread the word!
Tags: euthanasia, bioethics, medical ethics, hospitals, Not Dead Yet, Andrea Clark
UPDATE: I already got a response back from Stephen at Not Dead Yet; they just contacted the Texas NDY organizer to help out. Thanks, NDY!
UPDATE 2: Right Wing News’ John Hawkins is all over this, as he’s been in contact with the family and their lawyer. Stay tuned there for updates!


























ProLifeBlogs says:
Killing Andrea Clark - We are Protesting - Help Us
Here is an urgent action item aimed at helping stop Andrea Clark’s hospital from ending her life (Thanks to Beth). The message was apparently posted to the Democratic Underground by Andrea’s sister last Friday:KILLING MY SISTER - WE ARE PROTESTING…
chez Diva » Giving A Voice To Those… says:
[...] who’s voice can’t be heard. I saw this post at bamapachyderm and it touched me deeply. I will do as Beth did and re-post the whole thing. Please take a moment to make a difference in the life of someone who needs us . You can learn more about Andrea here. RightWingNews has more information on this case. The medical ethics board wants to end Andrea’s life on April 30th. Please help spread the word and save the life of Andrea Clarke. KILLING MY SISTER - WE ARE PROTESTING - HELP US [...]
Wizbang says:
Save Andrea Clarke
John Hawkins at Right Wing News has a heart wrenching story posted at Democratic Underground about Andrea Clarke whose doctors want to withhold treatment and allow her to die even though she is capable of communicating; however, she’s been medicated…
dawnsblood says:
Beth, I’ve e-mailed the President and called my senator (Burr) I don’t trust Libby Dole. Is there anything else I can do to help????
BlogsforTerri says:
We are Protesting the Killing of Andrea Clark - Help Us
Hopefully you’ve gathered that the action taken by the hospital is a step beyond what was done to Terri Schiavo. Perhaps a united front of bloggers can make a difference.
chez Diva says:
I’ve sent emails out to other bloggers I know so that they can spread the word. This case is frightening to say the least. This is what I expect in Europe (Holland to be specific) not here in the USA.
dawnsblood says:
Amen Chez… not on our watch!
Beth says:
Thanks, Diva and Dawn! As far as what else to do goes, I don’t know at this point!
At least other blogs are picking up on it, since NOBODY on the left seems to give a shi’ite outside that one dying DU thread. It’s sad.
chez Diva says:
I just saw that this story was picked up by memeorandum - maybe that will give it some exposure to other bloggers.
I did go to the DU link in the post and I was really surprised at the posts I saw. Thanks to John and you this message is getting out to other bloggers. I hope that we can effect change - this woman shouldn’t be handed a death sentence because the hospital “ethics” board deems it appropriate.
I can’t even begin to imagine the emotional pain Melanie and her family are experiencing. I will keep them in my prayers and will continue to do whatever I can to help.
Texas Rainmaker says:
A Houston Woman in Need
There is a woman at St. Luke’s Episcopal Hospital here in Houston that needs help.
In January, the 54-year-old underwent open-heart surgery. The next month she developed bleeding on the brain. Now an ethics committee has recommended removing her…
Stop The ACLU says:
Save A Life
John Hawkins has a request for your help to save a life. Bravo to John, the cause of life surpasses political lines.
Other: MVRWC
…
MY Vast Right Wing Conspiracy » Blog Archive » Update on Andrea Clarke says:
[...] This law has to be changed. Previously: Help Save Andrea Clark See also:Right Wing News, who reports that WND has now picked up the story. Hyscience, who’s all over this: Urgent help is needed from bloggers and blog readers (contact hospital and redistribute this story through your email lists). Please, immediately contact the hospital by telephone and email, and advise them of your horror that a faith-based hospital that supposedly respects life would act so irresponsibly as to put dollars before a patients life, etc…. : St. Luke’s Episcopal Hospital, 6720 Bertner Ave., Houston, TX 77030 Main hospital telephone number - 832-355-1000 Email (more to be updated later) [...]
euphoricreality.net says:
Another Life “Not Worth Living”
“Misery can only be removed from the world by painless extermination of the miserable.”
—a Nazi writer quoted by Robert J. Lifton in The Nazi Doctors: Medical Killing and the Psychology of Genocide
Here in Houston, a woman has been scheduled to …
MacStansbury.org » Blog Archive » Andrea Clark says:
[...] Help Save Andrea Clark [...]
Random Yak says:
Save Andrea Clarke
John Hawkins is spreading the word of a life that needs saving in Texas. I don’t know whether anyone reading here can help them save a life there, but I’m wi
Jerri Lynn Ward says:
Beth,
Thank you for posting this. I would like for people to know that I have not just one of these cases but TWO. I signed up as a volunteer on Texas Registry and got two at the same time. Because the family in my other case is not as media savy, I can’t seem to get the media interested in the case.
To me it is a disturbing case as well. It involves a woman named Yenlange T. Vo. She is in her 60’s. She has a diagnosis of PVS and is being dialyzed. She is at St. David’s North Austin Medical Center here in Austin.
The ethics committee decision seems to make the basis for withdrawal of the dialysis the fact that she is PVS–in other words based on her cognitive state. The hospital found a nursing facility willing to take her–but it is in Illinois and it will cost $7200 to transfer her. The law makes the family responsible for payment (if Medicare won’t pay). Plus, the family lives in Texas.
The ten days is up this Saturday. I am exploring legal actions in that case as well.
The Rogue Angel says:
Murdering Andrea Clark
Let’s call a spade a spade. When an insurance company pressures doctors to remove life support from a patient and those doctors take a meeting and decide that life support will be removed … against the patients wishes … it…